top of page

Reign of Christ Sunday: Good Trouble

2 days ago
4 min read

Matthew 25:31-46


Pastoral Visit, Virginia, Richard Norris Brooke, 1847-1920
Pastoral Visit, Virginia, Richard Norris Brooke, 1847-1920

Rev. Bobby Musengwa

Transitional General Presbyter


Last spring, two women walked into my office. Janice and Lydia are each a little bit of trouble on their own. 


Each is a formidable force of nature in advocating for justice for ‘the least of these,’ especially when it comes to issues Jesus cares about in Matthew 25.


Together, they are double trouble. Or, as John Lewis would put it, “good trouble.”


They had a simple proposal. 


They wanted the forthcoming General Assembly (GA227) gathering of the PCUSA to issue a statement on detention centers to bring greater justice and oversight to facilities. 


We have several detention centers right here in Mission Presbytery, and they believed silence was not an option. 


I walked them through the process. I told them it might already be too late to get their item on the General Assembly agenda. 


They were not deterred. I suggested they work with our GA commissioners, and off they went.


Janice contacted the Rev. Dr. Gini Norris-Lane, one of our Mission Presbytery commissioners. 


Together with others, including our own Rev. Dr. Josh Robinson, who moderated the GA’s Reformed Identity in the US committee, got the work onto the agenda, and the General Assembly in Milwaukee issued a powerful moral statement on detention centers’ reform and oversight. 


At our recent presbytery meeting at the First Korean Presbyterian Church in San Antonio, after our commissioners gave their report, Lydia stood up and asked us all to acknowledge Janice’s work. 


We all applauded Janice’s relentless work of justice and compassion.


I kept thinking about Janice and Lydia as I sat with Matthew 25. 


On this last Sunday of the church year, we finally see Jesus on his throne. 

He does not ask about our theological understanding or social or political leanings. 


He does not quiz us on what we believed or how often we showed up. He asks about lunch. 


He asks whether we noticed he was hungry. He also asks whether we have seen that he had been detained.


Jesus is on the Mount of Olives, finishing his last public teaching before the cross. 


The Son of Man comes in glory, the nations gather, and the shepherd-king sorts the flock. 


If you know Ezekiel 34, you hear the echo. God promised to shepherd the people personally, to bind up the injured and seek the lost. Matthew says that shepherd is Jesus.


Notice that the judgment is not between good people and monsters. 


Geoffrey Plant says it separates those who did good from those who did nothing. The goats are not accused of spectacular cruelty. They are accused of walking past. 


Plant tells the story of Elie Wiesel, who survived Auschwitz, and spent his life warning about this. Wiesel used to come to teach a course at Eckerd College, a Presbyterian college in St. Petersburg, just a mile from my former church.


Wiesel said the opposite of love is not hate but indifference. He never forgot the face in the window, the man who watched and felt nothing.


Janice and Lydia are the opposite of that face. They heard “it may be too late” and treated it as information, not a verdict. 


That is what good trouble looks like. It is what happens when someone refuses to be indifferent and keeps showing up until something changes.


Then comes the surprise in the text. Both groups ask the same question: 


“Lord, when did we see you?” Neither recognized him. 


The sheep were not collecting points. Their mercy had become so ordinary that they never kept score. 


Stanley Saunders notes that in the ancient world, gifts created obligations, so you gave to people who could pay you back. 


The hungry and the imprisoned could not. The sheep ignored that math entirely.


Scholars still debate who “the least of these” are. Some, like Warren Carter and Carla Works, hear a universal scope that includes every suffering person. 


Others read it as Jesus’ own vulnerable followers, in line with Matthew 10:40-42. 


Both readings agree that Scripture, from Deuteronomy to Isaiah to Proverbs, commands us to care for the stranger and the poor. 


Carter, a graduate of Princeton Theological Seminary, adds that suffering is often produced by systems, not just bad luck. 


So mercy means handing someone a meal, and it also means asking why the line for meals keeps growing. 


Or, in our case, why people are being held in a detention center down the road. That is where necessary trouble begins.


None of this is anxious scorekeeping. The kingdom, Jesus says, is inherited, prepared by the Father before the foundation of the world. 


Grace creates the kind of life that bears fruit, and judgment simply reveals it.


So here is my question for you this week. Who are the Janices and Lydias in your congregation, the ones who will not look away? 


Thank them out loud, the way Lydia thanked Janice. 


Then ask where Christ is hungry, a stranger, or locked away in your neighborhood right now. 


You have probably already met him. The only question left is what you did.


With peace,


Bobby




Comments


ABOUT US

As Mission Presbytery, we connect diverse leaders and congregations by providing opportunities for worship, learning, and service so that we can flourish through God's grace.

ADDRESS

210-826-3296

​

7201 Broadway

Ste. 303

San Antonio, TX 78209

​

missionpby@missionpby.org

Stay Connected

  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Instagram Social Icon
  • YouTube Social  Icon
Copy of Flourish Logo.png
abce0-pcusa-logo-white-e1438233158995.png
bottom of page